Butter Toffee

The Swiss Colony Customer Favorites with red stars

Milk Chocolate Covered Butter Toffee

Three sizes of red tins of butter toffee, with a tipped tin allowing some toffee to flow onto decorative plates.

The Swiss Colony’s Highest-Rated Product

“Do you have a higher rating than 5 stars? This toffee is incredible. Melt in your mouth incredible… If you haven’t tried this toffee, you are missing out on a delicious treat.”
–Michelle, Laconia, NH

Red dot divider.

Best-selling for a reason.

butter toffee samplers

Every single piece of Swiss Colony Butter Toffee is hand-poured, hand-fashioned and hand-packed for homemade care in every bite, and a melt-in-your-mouth flavor bursting with buttery goodness—the best you’ve ever tasted! In fact, our Butter Toffee is so mouth-wateringly delicious, it won the Wisconsin State Fair Seal of Excellence…but the most important awards it wins are in the hearts and minds of our customers:

“This is our favorite order at Christmas time! Smooth, melty chocolate, fantastic toffee and topped with nuts. What’s not to love?”
-Anonymous, North Aurora, IL

Red dot divider.

What is toffee made of?

Blocks of yellow butter, a bowl of white sugar, and scattered almonds on a marble surface.

1. Our award-winning Butter Toffee contains only the finest butter, almonds, and real sugar.

A large container spills a thick, golden mixture onto a metal surface, with two workers in white gloves overseeing the process.

2. Our candy chefs blend it all in fire-heated copper kettles, then pour it out to cool.

Hands in gloves handling a chocolate bar over a tray filled with broken pieces of caramel.


3.
 During cooling, the toffee is scored into individual pieces, which are then broken apart by hand.

Melted chocolate drizzling over caramel pieces on a wire rack, with some caramel pooling on the surface below.

4. Each piece is drenched in a special blend of milk chocolate used only for our toffee.

Chocolate-covered treats on a cooling rack, sprinkled with crumbs, with melted chocolate dripping down.

5. After a final dusting of ground almonds, this incredible toffee is ready to enjoy!

Red dot divider.

Addictively delicious toffee.

“These toffees are so delicious, it was hard to stop eating them!”
-Baograd, Keene, NH

Our super-buttery toffee, coated in some of the creamiest milk chocolate you’ll ever taste, results in a decadent flavor that can only be described as addictive. We dare you to eat only one piece…but don’t take our word for it; read what our customers tell us:

Five red stars above a glowing testimonial praising a toffee product for its irresistible taste and popularity.
Five-star review praising Butter Toffee, highlighting its addictive nature and family love for the product.
Five red stars accompany a glowing customer review praising butter toffee from Warren, Sandyston, NJ.
Five red stars above a glowing review praising the best butter toffee, signed by an anonymous reviewer from Rhinelander, WI.
Five-star review praising the best butter toffee, highly recommended by Sheila from New Castle, PA.
Red dot divider.